My reason for declining comes from a series of reasons.
But the main one is that the guild as a whole, does not need this kind of drama, and will not stand for it. We cannot, and will not take sides, as no matter what anyone says, we have no way of telling who is telling the truth. So, best solution is just end this at its source. For more details, read Darklords application.
Let this also stand as a message to those who try to "sabotage" applications, DO NOT DO IT ON OUR FORUMS. If you have something to tell the officer's about the players you see apply, whisper us ingame in a polite manner, or just send us an ingame mail.
As said before, the guild does not require this kind of drama, application denied.